Priority area 1 – Legal safeguards
Young girl, informant in the report Det var ikke bare ferie [It wasn’t just a holiday] by the Expert Group on Children and Young People Who Are Left Abroad Against Their Will (2020) (available in Norwegian only).
The Government will strengthen the legal safeguards of children, young people and adults subjected to negative social control and honour-motivated violence.
The Government is strengthening its efforts and proposing several legal measures to prevent and combat negative social control and honour-motivated violence. Norwegian Official Report (NOU) (2024) 13 Lov og frihet [Law and Freedom] (available in Norwegian only) is an important basis for the Government’s continued efforts. The Committee has made a number of specific recommendations and proposals for legislative amendments to strengthen the legal safeguards of individuals at risk of or subjected to negative social control, honour-motivated violence, and similar practices. The report shows that legislation is indeed an important part of the broad range of measures aimed at protecting the right to freedom and safety from negative social control and honour-motivated violence.
For the Government, the goal is to criminalise more serious acts and ensure that those who commit honour-motivated violence, force others into marriage, or subject children to female genital mutilation are held accountable. The Government also wants a targeted effort for children and young people who are, or are at risk of being, subjected to such acts.
Norway was among the early countries to adopt its own penal provisions criminalising female genital mutilation and forced marriage, and in recent years several legislative amendments have been adopted that have strengthened the legal safeguards of victims, including the following:
- The penal provision on forced marriage has been amended so that it also applies to non-legal forced marriages.
- The duty to avert a criminal act under the Norwegian Penal Code has been extended to include the averting of forced marriages and marriages involving children under 16 years of age, including non-legal marriages involving children under 16.
- A prohibition has been introduced against marriages between first cousins, and the Norwegian Marriage Act has been strengthened to combat child marriages.
Box 5: NOU 2024: 13 Lov og frihet [Law and Freedom] (available in Norwegian only)
In September 2021, a public committee led by Professor Henriette Sinding Aasen was appointed. The committee was mandated to investigate the overall legal issues in cases concerning negative social control, honour-based violence, forced marriage, female genital mutilation and psychological violence. The committee submitted its report Norwegian Official Report (NOU) 2024: 13 Lov og frihet [Law and Freedom] (available in Norwegian only) on 21 June 2024. The report provides a comprehensive review of the legal issues in cases involving negative social control and the extent to which victims have adequate legal safeguards.
The law committee has made a number of recommendations and more than 60 specific proposals for legislative amendments, including:
- important clarifications of key terms such as negative social control, honour-motivated violence and involuntary stay abroad.
- amendments to the Norwegian Penal Code, including that the provisions on domestic abuse are better adapted to the special features of honour-motivated violence cases. Furthermore, that forced marriages and child marriages be included as purposes of exploitation in the provision on human trafficking. A stricter and more comprehensive provision on child marriage is also proposed, which highlights the motive of honour as an aggravating circumstance.
- measures and regulations in the Norwegian Children Act and the Norwegian Child Welfare Act, including that emphasis be placed on whether the child’s right to participation and self-determination has been seriously violated when assessing whether there is reason to believe that a child is being subjected to serious neglect.
- measures before, during and after an involuntary stay abroad, including proposals for a travel ban in the Norwegian Child Welfare Act and aftercare for at-risk children. There are also proposed competence enhancement measures regarding the duty to report to the child welfare services when there is reason to believe that a child is or will be subjected to a harmful stay abroad.
The report has been subject to public consultation, and more than 80 consultation responses have been received.
Measure 1: Strengthen the legal safeguards of victims of honour-motivated violence, with a particular focus on children and young people
The Government believes that the legislative proposals in Norwegian Official Report (NOU) 2024: 13 Lov og frihet [Law and Freedom] (available in Norwegian only) are an important part of the broad range of measures aimed at protecting the right to freedom and safety from negative social control and honour-motivated violence. There is a need to promptly assess the committee’s proposals and implement any legislative changes deemed necessary. During the Action Plan period, the Government will review the proposals in the NOU. This will be a highly prioritised effort.
- a) A targeted effort for children and young people
- The Government wants to implement the necessary legislative changes to strengthen the legal safeguards of children and young people, with particular consideration given to:
- amendments to the regulation of child marriage and whether forced marriage and child marriage should be included as purposes of exploitation in the Norwegian Penal Code’s provision on human trafficking.
- better protection measures for children subjected to forced marriage and female genital mutilation.
- Responsible government ministries: Ministry of Justice and Public Security, Ministry of Children and Families, and Ministry of Labour and Social Inclusion
- b) Strengthen criminal legal protection for victims in cases of honour-motivated violence
- The Government wants to strengthen the criminal legal protection of victims in cases of honour-motivated violence, and will in particular consider:
- amendments to the regulation of honour-motivated crime, and in particular whether the Norwegian Penal Code’s provision on domestic abuse should be better adapted to the special features of honour-motivated violence cases.
- whether the group of people who can be prosecuted for contraventions of the Norwegian Penal Code’s provision on domestic abuse should be extended.
- whether a motive of honour should be specifically mentioned as an aggravating circumstance in the Norwegian Penal Code.
- Responsible government ministries: Ministry of Justice and Public Security and Ministry of Labour and Social Inclusion
Measure 2: Legal regulation of the specialised public services that prevent and avert negative social control and honour-motivated violence and provide assistance in individual cases
The specialised services, described in Box 3, carry out preventive work and provide guidance and assistance in individual cases. The cases often contain highly sensitive information that is collected and shared between multiple public bodies. These services are not specifically regulated in the legislation. An external report concludes that parts of the specialised services do not have an adequate legal basis for collecting, storing, using and disclosing personal data, and recommends that the processing of personal data be regulated by law.
The Government will submit for public hearing a proposal for legal regulation of the specialised services that prevent and avert negative social control and honour-motivated violence and the safeguarding of privacy.
Responsible government ministry: Ministry of Labour and Social Inclusion
Box 6: Report on honour killings in Norway
In the intelligence report Æresdrap i Norge 2020-2022 [honour killings in Norway 2020–2022] (available in Norwegian only), the National Criminal Investigation Service (Kripos) states that the extent of honour killings is difficult to determine both nationally and internationally since homicides are often not registered according to motive, and it can be difficult to distinguish honour killings from other homicides unless honour has been a key part of the investigation.
The report concludes that it is likely that at least 24 honour killings were committed or ordered in Norway in the period 2000–2022. Very few of the cases have been identified, investigated and prosecuted as honour killings by the police and prosecuting authority. The motive of honour is mentioned in the actual judgment in only six of the cases.
Honour killings are organised homicides. In 11 out of 24 cases, there is concrete information that someone other than the perpetrator passively or actively supported or was complicit in the actual homicide. In only one of the cases has an individual been convicted of complicity.
The report points out that honour killings are forewarned homicides. In a majority of the cases, the family was aware of concrete death threats or plans prior to the homicide, and in more than half of the cases, the victim reported the perpetrator for violence or death threats prior to being killed. In six cases, the victim was killed a few months after the incident was reported to the police.